2020 Player Breakdowns

Anthony Edwards Breakdown


Overall Edwards is a very talented player but it felt like he wasn’t working as hard as he could.  By that I mean it feels like when he beats the first level defender going down hill off ball or off ball screen he’ll struggle with decision making when the second level comes rotating over.  When met with the second level he’ll tend to shoot pull up mid range jumpers instead of working the defender deeper or threading the play along with instinctive passing.  He has the strength and athletic ability to fend off defenders on his drive then shed them at the rim.  He has a nice low center change of direction move which he uses a between the legs cross or a pull back cross and go.  He’ll in-and-out you out of your shoes, absorb contact at the rim and finish with control.  He has the ability to work the defense deeper middle off live-dribble but when faced with a decision at the second level he gets passive with pull ups.  This may change over time since it’s more of a mental block.  When you’re a good pick-and-roll scorer you should be adept at turning the corner or rejecting the screen but it seems like he’s a far better driver when he rejects the screen.  A lot of that has to do with the fact when he rejects the screen the big help defender is deeper in the paint rather than corralling his drive up close.  He likes to have a runway on his drives.  He doesn’t have an advanced shooting portfolio but is a decent tough shot maker displaying a pull back jumper halting his momentum on a dime and pulling back with a cross.  He’s not really an instinctive play maker but has used the advantages off his scoring ability and leveraged that into creation.  However he’s a better passer in transition rather than half court execution even though he does display fine rhythm off pick-and-roll passing.  He’s decent at reading the first action but any sort of sequence of events and he can struggle to read the court.


When Edwards gets his legs underneath his chest, has active feet, sturdy armbar and slides with purpose containing dribble penetration, man, he shows how tough it could be fighting for angles downhill; really good on-ball defense.  Unfortunately he doesn’t show much consistency in his fundamentals.  Sometimes he’ll poorly shade the ball handler, other times he won’t use an armbar and then when he does get beat versus the first step he’ll get handsy and hand check the drive.  Also more than what I would’ve liked to see was Edwards dying midpost after he lost the drive first level, it’s like he’s getting ready to brace for the rebound or maybe he’s getting ready for a quick inbounds play even though he could still funnel the ball handler.  He’ll also have lapses versus early offense and do a poor job matching up.  It’s tough to tell defensive communication 100% of the time just by watching a lot of televised games but a play that stuck out was one of his teammates pointing out an off ball switch early and Edwards didn’t pay it any mind resulting in an easy bucket.  Was it poor communication, was it poor processing speed, was it poor effort or was it a little of all?  Edwards has demonstrated he can play good on-ball defense, he’s shown the ability to rotate on middle drives and add that to his positive hand eye coordination feeding his creation Edwards has illustrated his pro defensive capability.  The issue however might be if he can sustain a full game of that level of defense.

2020 Player Breakdowns

Aaron Nesmith Breakdown


One of the best three point shooters in the class.  It’s a shame his season ended early with an injury but it left his three point percentage at 52% which is absurd.  And it’s not like it was only 4 games, it was 14 games.  The pump fake, side step, re-load pull ups are part of his repertoire but his most interesting shooting aspect is his movement shooting.  He can cleanly round corners off screens, catch on the move and stop on a dime raise up from deep.  His core stability gives him balance when his body is tilting momentum.  At times he’ll do the whole kick out his legs thing when a defender cuts off his landing space on jump shots.  You have to do what you have to do to get the call but it clearly affects his shooting ability for the negative.  He has a high release point on his jumper which helps verse contested shots which happens a decent amount.  On his drives he will lean into the defender forcing the player to put extra weight on the back of his feet then dislodge the player with a slight nudge creating separation in the process.  He has a NBA quality first step, drives mostly in a straight line with little shift or sudden movements, dips his shoulder into defender, holds off defender with arm guard then get to the rim but has trouble consistently finishing over contact.  He has good body control and coordination so he needs to do a better job with off timing his gather, follow his extension through and finishing with his off hand.  As a playmaker Nesmith is a line of sight passer.  Unless the play is unfolding right in front of his eyes it’s tough for him to sense breaking action peripherally.  He would beat the first level defender live-dribble, draw in the second level and will have tunnel vision missing players long corner or short corner.  Even though his decision making ability will be a question mark moving forward he can still play make of his scoring ability and create off those gained advantages.


Watching Nesmith on defense is pretty misleading.  You see a player with a wide defensive base and athletic ability and think how tough he is to drive on.  It looks like he’s moving around the court all nimble but the closer you watch the more you see him play flat footed.  He should be playing on his toes and staying coiled but instead plays back on his heels with poor balance.  He’ll have poor foot positioning on-ball and give up too wide of an angle.  He doesn’t leverage his body as much as he needs to and needs more integrity on his slides while funneling dribble penetration.  When he does stay attached he demonstrates a strong arm bar rerouting the drive and long armed mirroring which means he has the ability to be a better on-ball defender.  He’s a mixed bag on team defense.  At times you’ll see him make well timed low man rotations to wall off the drive but then the very next play will slide out of position prematurely and leave the driver with no help middle.  He’ll stay at home and stick to his own when he should be helping the helper.  He’ll also be a step slow on rotations and rarely cycles through assignments.  He can create on defense by getting hand on ball for deflections, steals and blocks but will take unnecessary gambles and lazy swipe down fouls.

2020 Player Breakdowns

Tyrese Haliburton Breakdown


Fantastic off ball player.  Nice backdoor cut when reading teammates dribble push and flashes baseline as soon as help started to crowd ball handler.  Nice relocation off dribble drive passes and climbs to the open spot.  Has great touch around the rim but can struggle at times over height/size due to lack of pop and strength. Can’t really break guys down off the dribble so he attempts a lot of 1-2 plant pull ups.  Not really a tough shot maker but does attempt step backs, off screen and altered momentum shots; has shown some semblance of ability.  Uses his high level long range shooting ability to set up his drives whether that’s attacking a hard closeout or just using pump fakes.  Off ball screens he utilizes acceleration/deceleration moves down hill to get defenders momentum leaning.  Doesn’t have a lot burst but his change of speed game is solid.  The lack of a great first step probably hinders his upside.  Also off ball screens does great job anticipating defenders angles and whether to reject the screen or dribble off it to get down hill.  When he does get into the paint rarely draws fouls.  It could be because he isn’t versed in gathering by relying on his left foot leap, right hand finishes on both sides of the rim or maybe because he shrinks away from contact midair.  Although I will say he isn’t afraid to leap in the muck for an offensive rebound.  One of the best players in this draft when it comes to processing speed.  Reads plays before they break whether that’s off the bounce or pick-and-roll.  Very methodical turning the corner off ball screens and is patient waiting for the right loose end to reveal itself.  Very smart player overall.


One of the best at defensive creation for a guard in this class.  He has great hand eye coordination, great timing, and is quick to process the action.  He’s not afraid to leave his man or position to suffocate the action and force a havoc shifting play.  Although when he does leave his man or position his return home can be late.  His lack of closing speed is one of his biggest defensive constraints.  Also another impediment is his lack of fluid hips verse point of attack.  Doesn’t really flip his hips that well and can be susceptible to opening his hips too early.  However he does have great on-ball fundamentals by playing on the balls of his feet, staying coiled, strong armbar and strong balance.  He also has a wide base and solid defensive slide positioning.  The lack of a strong butt and anchor can be troublesome when absorbing offensive blows and controlling a ball handlers hips.  One of his biggest issues on team defense is at times he’ll ball watch and get lost in space.  He’s a heady enough player to reestablish ball-and-man but it feels like every so often he’ll be more interested in getting a steal rather than play sound team defense.  With that said though he’ll make nice low-man vertical contests from the weak side, shrink the court and crash down on third level rotations.

2020 Player Breakdowns

OldManBasketball’s NBA Draft Grade Sparknotes

The 2020 NBA draft is the first year I’m doing draft grades.  It definitely has been a process for me with a lot of trial and error.  I wanted to be as thorough and impartial as possible with the grades.  There are 30 categories on offense to grade and 15 to grade on defense with sliding weights given to different positions.  It’s taken me time to figure out what value belongs to each category and what markers make up the criteria.  I’ve also incorporated advanced stats and developed formulas to create grades.  For example something like ‘touch’.  

None of this is perfect and not anywhere close to a finished product.  As a result there won’t be as many completed player grades as I was hoping to post.  I’ve scouted over 60 players but unfortunately will be able to grade around 15-30 before the draft.  I technically could keep posting grades after the draft but I’m not sure if that’s necessary.  I want to start focusing on next year’s draft and especially the 2022 draft when hopefully the basketball world will be a little more normal.  I’ve gotten my grading procedure down to a suitable level now and with future drafts should be keeping grades up to date during the season.

For this year’s crop of player grades I’ll have a sortable table with player breakdowns linked.  If you’ve followed me in the past I typically write extensive scouting reports on each player but due to time constraints will be writing brief player breakdowns instead.

OldManBasketball’s NBA Draft Grade Sparknotes

The players will be graded on OFFENSE and DEFENSE.  OFFENSE will be graded on shooting, screen setting/pick-and-roll game (for bigs only), scoring/finishing, driving/handle, feel and creation/passing.  Each category has its own grouping of skills totaling 30 to 35.  For example, drawing fouls on the gather/rim, movement shooting and win rate of drives.  DEFENSE will be graded on team defense, on-ball defense, creation and IQ.  Each category has its own grouping of skills totaling 15.  For example spatial awareness and help defense.  The more markers the player hits the better the grade.  OFFENSE and DEFENSE will be graded on a 1-99 scale:


95-99: God Status (generational skills)

85-94: Elite (all-nba skills)

75-84: Great (all-star skills)

65-74: Good (starter level skill)

55-64: Above Average (rotation player skills)

45-54:  Average (bench player skills)

35-44: Below Average (g-league lifer skills)

1-34: Poor (not in league skills)


There will also be ROLE POTENTIAL which features a ‘high’ and ‘low’ outlook.  For example, HIGH: swiss army knife big, LOW: rim-running backup big.  There will be STAR POTENTIAL which factors in functional athleticism and physical profile aka athletic ability, height, wingspan, lateral agility, shoulder size, etc.  It is graded on a 1-99 scale.  Just because player x graded better than player y doesn’t mean I project player x to be the ‘better’ player.  Incorporating STAR POTENTIAL can act like a tipping point.  I’ll also try to have SYSTEM DEPENDENCE included which entails the list of teams that will enhance a players skills and which teams could hamper them.  Basically ‘team fit’ potential.  If I do complete ‘system dependence’ it won’t be located on the sortable table and will be with the PLAYER BREAKDOWN (which you can find by clicking the players name).  The more players I grade and more film I watch the grades are always subject to change.  I’ll expand upon how in depth I go into the grades at a later date.

2020 NBA Draft Grades

2020 NBA Draft Grades (1st Edition)

Click HERE to get a better idea what these grades mean.

Click on player names for further breakdown (grades are subject to change as we get closer to draft night):


NameOffenseDefenseRoleStar Potential
Kira Lewis 70.9462.57HIGH: Lead Initiator
LOW: Backup Ball Handler
Tyrese Haliburton69.2568.61H: All-Time Glue Guy
L: Backup 3-and-D combo guard
Aaron Nesmith66.6257.22H: Top Tier Scoring Wing
L: Backup Shooting Specialist
Anthony Edwards67.7560.59H: Two-Way Wing Initiator L: Microwave Scorer Off Bench81
Tyrell Terry7257.1H: Shot Creating Lead Ball Handler
L: Movement Shooting Combo Guard
Devin Vassell62.567.5H: 3-and-D Hybrid Wing
L: Spot Up Shooting Guard
Isaac Okoro65.3770.09H: Scoring Wing W/Elite Defense
L: Defensive Specialist
Grant Riller74.3756.53H: Lead Initiator
L: Backup Scoring Guard
Isaiah Joe62.6261.78H: Two-Way Movement Shooter
L: Defensive Liability Spot Up Shooter
Mason Jones69.1256.19H: Shot Creating Wing
L: Matchup dependent Bench Scorer
Cole Anthony72.2557H: Primary Ball Handler
L: Bench Scorer
Tyrese Maxey70.3760.16H: High Level Secondary Ball Handler
L: Bench Scoring Combo Guard


NameOffenseDefenseRoleStar Potential
Onyeka Okongwu66.5870HIGH: Elite Two-Way Big
LOW: Backup Rim-Runner
Obi Toppin67.3562.33H: Elite Scoring Big
L: Hustle Bench Big